Short Circuit Current Analysis Guide

Introduction

When a fault occurs in an electrical system, current surges to thousands of amperes in milliseconds—and every protective device in the path must safely interrupt this current or face catastrophic failure. Short circuit analysis determines these fault currents and ensures protection devices can handle them.

Why This Calculation Matters

A circuit breaker rated for 10 kA cannot safely interrupt a 15 kA fault—it may explode, arc flash, or fail to clear the fault, cascading damage through the electrical system. Short circuit analysis identifies fault current magnitudes at every point in the distribution system, enabling proper selection of breakers, fuses, and other protective devices. Without this analysis, protection devices become potential hazards rather than safety measures.

The Fundamental Challenge

Fault current magnitude depends on system impedance—lower impedance means higher fault current. The transformer's impedance dominates near the transformer, but cable impedance increasingly limits fault current at downstream locations. A panel 100 meters from the transformer might see half the fault current of the main switchboard. This distance-dependent attenuation affects protection device selection throughout the distribution system, requiring calculations at each protection point.

What You'll Learn

This guide covers short circuit analysis methodology per IEC 60909-0:2016 standards. You'll master calculating transformer, cable, and system impedances, determine fault current magnitudes at various system locations, and select protection devices with appropriate breaking capacity. Practical examples demonstrate the complete workflow from utility data through final breaker selection with safety margins.

Quick Answer: How to Calculate Short Circuit Current

Short circuit current is calculated using the IEC 60909 formula, accounting for system voltage and total impedance.

Core Formula

Where:

• $I_{\text{sc}}$ = Short circuit current (A or kA)
• $c$ = Voltage factor (1.1 for maximum fault, 0.95 for minimum)
• $U_n$ = Nominal system potential, line-to-line (V)
• $Z_{\text{total}}$ = Total system impedance (Ω)

Worked Example

Reference Table

Key Standards

Impedance Components

Worked Example

Reference Table

Key Standards

Typical Fault Currents

Breaking capacity categories (IEC 60947-2):

• Low: 6-10 kA (residential, small commercial)
• Medium: 16-25 kA (commercial buildings)
• High: 35-50 kA (industrial facilities)
• Very High: 65-100 kA (power plants, substations)

Critical factors:

• Conductor length reduces fault amp: 100m electrical line $\rightarrow$ 30-50% reduction
• Always add 25% safety margin for breaker selection
• Use c=1.1 for device sizing, c=0.95 for coordination
• Temperature affects resistance: 70°C for cables, 90°C for busbars

Standard: IEC 60909-0:2016 (international) | ANSI/IEEE C37.010 (USA) | Circuit breakers per IEC 60947-2

Understanding Short Circuit Current

What Are the Types of Short Circuits?

Three-Phase Fault (L-L-L): All three phases short-circuited together. This produces the highest fault electrical flow and is used for protection device sizing.

Line-to-Line Fault (L-L): Two phases short-circuited together. Amp is approximately 87% of three-phase fault electric current.

Line-to-Ground Fault (L-G): One phase short-circuited to ground. I value depends on equipment grounding and is typically 50-70% of three-phase fault amperage.

Factors Affecting Short Circuit Current

Transformer Impedance: Lower impedance transformers produce higher fault currents. Typical values:

• Distribution transformers (up to 2,500 kVA): 4-6%
• Power transformers (2,500+ kVA): 5-12%
• Generator transformers: 10-20%

Infrastructure Electric tension: Higher voltages result in lower fault currents for the same power rating.

Setup Impedance: Upstream arrangement impedance reduces fault electrical flow. Categories:

• Strong mechanism: 0-2% (close to generation, large transformers)
• Medium installation: 2-5% (typical distribution)
• Weak equipment: 5-10% (remote locations, small transformers)

Electrical line Impedance: Long cables between the transformer and fault location significantly reduce fault amp.

Formula Breakdown

Basic Formula (IEC 60909)

The fundamental formula for calculating three-phase short circuit current per IEC 60909-0:2016 is:

Where:

• $I_{\text{sc}}$ = Short circuit current (A or kA)
• $c$ = Voltage factor (1.1 for maximum fault current, 0.95 for minimum)
• $U_n$ = Nominal voltage, line-to-line (V)
• $Z_{\text{total}}$ = Total system impedance ($\Omega$)

Voltage Factor ($c$):

The voltage factor accounts for system voltage variations during faults:

Standard Reference: IEC 60909-0:2016, Clause 4 - Voltage factors for different system types.

Transformer Impedance

Transformer impedance in ohms is calculated from the nameplate data:

Where:

• $Z_t$ = Transformer impedance ($\Omega$)
• $U_n$ = Nominal voltage (V)
• $S_n$ = Rated apparent power (VA or kVA)
• $Z_{\%}$ = Transformer impedance percentage (%)

Example: For a 630 kVA, 400V transformer with 6% impedance:

• $S_n = 630,000$ VA
• $Z_{\%} = 6\%$
• $Z_t = \frac{400^2}{630,000} \times \frac{6}{100} = \frac{160,000}{630,000} \times 0.06 = 0.0152 \Omega$

Typical Transformer Impedances:

Cable Impedance

Cable impedance consists of resistance and reactance:

Resistance (temperature-corrected):

$R = \frac{\rho(T) \times L}{A}$

Reactance (typical values):

• Low voltage cables: 0.07-0.08 mΩ/m
• Medium voltage cables: 0.10-0.12 mΩ/m
• High voltage cables: 0.13-0.15 mΩ/m

Where:

• $R$ = Cable resistance ($\Omega$)
• $X$ = Cable reactance ($\Omega$)
• $\rho(T)$ = Resistivity at temperature $T$ ($\Omega \cdot \text{mm}^2/\text{m}$)
• $L$ = Conductor length (m)
• $A$ = Cross-sectional area (mm²)

Temperature Correction:

For copper conductors, resistivity increases with temperature:

$\rho(T) = \rho_{20} \times [1 + \alpha \times (T - 20)]$

Where:

• $\rho_{20}$ = Resistivity at 20°C (0.0175 $\Omega \cdot \text{mm}^2/\text{m}$ for copper)
• $\alpha$ = Temperature coefficient (0.00393 /°C for copper)
• $T$ = Operating temperature (°C)

System Impedance

Additional system impedance (upstream from transformer):

$Z_{\text{system}} = \frac{U_n^2}{S_n} \times \frac{Z_{\%}}{100}$

Where:

• $Z_{\text{system}}$ = System impedance ($\Omega$)
• $U_n$ = Nominal voltage (V)
• $S_n$ = Short-circuit power of upstream system (VA)
• $Z_{\%}$ = System impedance percentage (%)

Typical System Impedance Values:

Total Impedance

The total impedance is the sum of all impedance components:

$Z_{\text{total}} = Z_t + Z_{\text{cable}} + Z_{\text{system}}$

Where:

• $Z_{\text{total}}$ = Total impedance ($\Omega$)
• $Z_t$ = Transformer impedance ($\Omega$)
• $Z_{\text{cable}}$ = Cable impedance ($\Omega$)
• $Z_{\text{system}}$ = System impedance ($\Omega$)

Impedance Components Summary:

Worked Example: Commercial Building

Scenario

A commercial building is supplied by a 1,000 kVA transformer at 400V with 6% impedance. The electrical room is located 50 meters from the transformer. We need to evaluate the short circuit electrical flow at the main distribution panel.

Given Data

• Transformer wattage: $S_n = 1000$ kVA
• Mechanism potential: $U_n = 400$ V
• Transformer impedance: $Z_{\%} = 6$%
• Electrical line: $3 \times 150$ mm² copper, 50m length
• Operating heat level: 70°C
• Installation impedance: 2% (medium strength equipment)

Step 1: Calculate Transformer Impedance

Step 2: Calculate Cable Impedance

Cable impedance has two components: resistance and reactance.

Given:

• Cable: $3 \times 150$ mm² copper, 50 m length
• Operating temperature: 70°C
• Low voltage cable reactance: 0.07 mΩ/m

Cable Resistance:

For copper at 70°C, use resistivity $\rho_{70} = 0.0209 \Omega \cdot \text{mm}^2/\text{m}$:

Cable Reactance:

Total Cable Impedance:

Step 3: Calculate System Impedance

System impedance represents the upstream network impedance (utility supply):

Where:

• $U_n = 400$ V (nominal voltage)
• $S_n = 1,000,000$ VA (short-circuit power, typically 1 MVA for medium systems)
• $Z_{\%} = 2\%$ (system impedance percentage)

Step 4: Calculate Total Impedance

Sum all impedance components:

Substituting values:

Impedance Breakdown:

Step 5: Calculate Short Circuit Current

Using voltage factor $c = 1.1$ (maximum fault current):

Step 6: Determine Breaking Capacity Requirement

With 25% safety margin:

#Our calculations follow industry best practices and have been validated against real-world scenarios.

Conclusion

The main distribution panel requires circuit breakers with a minimum breaking capacity of 15.4 kA. Standard industrial circuit breakers rated at 25 kA would be appropriate for this application.

Export as PDF — Generate professional reports for documentation, client presentations, or permit submissions.

Standards and References

IEC 60909

IEC 60909-0:2016 - "Short-circuit currents in three-phase a.c. systems"

This is the primary international standard for calculating short-circuit currents. It provides:

• Methods for calculating maximum and minimum short-circuit currents
• Electric tension factors for different setup configurations
• Impedance calculation methods
• Correction factors for generators and motors

IEC 61363

IEC 61363-1:1998 - "Short-circuit electric current computation for three-phase a.c. systems"

Alternative analysis method, particularly useful for:

• Systems with significant motor contribution
• Complex network configurations
• Detailed transient analysis

ANSI/IEEE Standards

ANSI/IEEE C37.010-2016 - "Application Guide for AC High-Volt level Circuit Breakers"

US standard covering:

• Circuit breaker application
• Short-circuit I value calculations
• Protection coordination principles

IEC 60947-2

IEC 60947-2 - "Low-potential switchgear and controlgear - Part 2: Circuit-breakers"

Defines:

• Breaking capacity ratings
• Making capacity requirements
• Short-time withstand ratings

Common Mistakes and Pitfalls

Mistake 1: Ignoring Cable Impedance

Problem: Calculating fault current at transformer secondary only, ignoring downstream cables.

Impact: Overestimating fault current at load locations, leading to oversized and unnecessarily expensive protection devices.

Solution: Always include cable impedance when the fault occurs downstream from the transformer. Cable impedance can reduce fault current by 20-40% in typical installations.

Mistake 2: Using Incorrect Temperature

Problem: Using room thermal reading (20°C) for resistance calculations when conductors operate at higher temperatures.

Impact: Underestimating resistance, leading to overestimated fault amp.

Solution: Use actual operating heat (typically 70°C for cables, 90°C for busbars).

Mistake 3: Neglecting System Impedance

Problem: Assuming infinite source (zero system impedance) for all calculations.

Impact: Overestimating fault current in systems with significant upstream impedance. This can lead to:

• Oversized circuit breakers
• Unnecessary protection costs
• Incorrect coordination studies

Solution: Include system impedance based on:

• Distance from generation source
• Transformer size and configuration
• Network topology
• Utility supply characteristics

Typical System Impedance Values:

• Strong utility systems: 0.5-2%
• Medium systems: 2-5%
• Weak systems (remote generation): 5-10%

Mistake 4: Incorrect Voltage Factor

Problem: Using $c = 1.0$ instead of $c = 1.1$ for maximum fault I value calculations.

Impact: Underestimating fault amperage by approximately 10%.

Solution: Use $c = 1.1$ for maximum fault electrical flow (protection device sizing) and $c = 0.95$ for minimum fault amp (protection coordination).

Mistake 5: Insufficient Safety Margin

Problem: Selecting circuit breakers with breaking capacity exactly matching calculated fault electric current.

Impact: No margin for:

• Determination uncertainties
• Future installation changes
• Thermal value variations
• Aging effects

Solution: Apply minimum 25% safety margin for breaking capacity selection.

Using the Enginist Short Circuit Calculator

Our calculator implements IEC 60909 methodology with the following features:

Input Parameters

Equipment Configuration:

• Infrastructure electrical potential (line-to-line)
• Operating degree

Transformer Data:

• Rated load (kVA)
• Secondary V value
• Percentage impedance
• Optional: Setup impedance

Fault Location:

• At transformer secondary
• On load side (with electrical line parameters)

Wiring Parameters (if fault on load side):

• Length
• Cross-sectional area
• Conductor material (copper/aluminum)

Output Results

Fault I value:

• Short circuit amperage in amperes and kiloamperes
• Breaking capacity requirement with safety margin

Impedance Breakdown:

• Transformer impedance
• Lead impedance (if applicable)
• Arrangement impedance
• Total impedance
• Per-unit impedance

Warnings and Recommendations:

• Breaking capacity category (low/medium/high/very high)
• Safety warnings for high fault currents
• Recommendations for protection device selection

Accuracy and Standards

• Compliance: Full IEC 60909 implementation
• Accuracy: Validated against standard reference values
• Heat level Correction: Automatic resistivity adjustment
• Material Properties: Based on IEC 60028 standard values

Protection Device Selection

Breaking Capacity Categories

Low (up to 10 kA):

• Typical for: Residential, small commercial
• Circuit breakers: Standard MCBs, MCCBs up to 10 kA

Medium (10-25 kA):

• Typical for: Commercial buildings, small industrial
• Circuit breakers: MCCBs rated 16-25 kA

High (25-50 kA):

• Typical for: Industrial facilities, large commercial
• Circuit breakers: High breaking capacity MCCBs, ACBs

Very High (50+ kA):

• Typical for: Capacity plants, large industrial complexes
• Circuit breakers: Special high-capacity ACBs, generator breakers

How Do You Select?

1. Breaking Capacity: Must exceed calculated fault electrical flow by at least 25%
2. Making Capacity: Typically $2.5 \times$ breaking capacity
3. Short-Time Withstand: Must handle fault amp for protection coordination time
4. Thermal Rating: Must withstand $I^2t$ let-through energy
5. Electromagnetic Rating: Must withstand peak fault electric current forces

Conclusion

Short circuit current analysis is fundamental to electrical system safety and reliability. Understanding the principles, formulas, and calculation methods enables engineers to design safe and compliant electrical systems, select appropriate protection devices, coordinate protection schemes effectively, and ensure personnel and equipment safety. The IEC 60909 standard provides a robust, internationally recognized methodology for short-circuit current calculations. By following this standard and applying proper safety margins, engineers can confidently design electrical protection systems that meet all safety and code requirements.

Key Takeaways

• Short circuit current is calculated using IEC 60909 formula: $I_{sc} = \frac{c \times U_n}{\sqrt{3} \times Z_{total}}$, where c is voltage factor (1.1 for maximum fault) and $Z_{total}$ includes transformer, cable, and system impedances
• Short circuit currents can be 10-50 times normal operating current, requiring proper protection device selection with minimum 25% safety margin
• Transformer impedance is the primary limiting factor—lower impedance (4-6%) produces higher fault currents than high impedance (8-12%) transformers
• Cable impedance significantly reduces fault current at load locations—every 100m of cable reduces fault current by 30-50% depending on cable size
• Always apply safety margins for protection device selection—breaking capacity must exceed calculated fault current by at least 25% per IEC 60947-2
• Calculate fault current at each protection device location, not just at transformer, to optimize breaker sizing and reduce equipment costs

Further Learning

• Cable Sizing Guide - Understanding how cable impedance affects short circuit current
• Voltage Drop Guide - Related calculations for electrical system design
• Transformer Sizing Guide - How transformer impedance affects fault currents
• Short Circuit Calculator - Interactive calculator with IEC 60909 methodology

References & Standards

This guide follows established engineering principles and standards. For detailed requirements, always consult the current adopted edition in your jurisdiction.

Primary Standards

IEC 60909-0:2016 Short-circuit currents in three-phase a.c. systems - Part 0: Calculation of currents. Provides the international standard methodology for short-circuit current calculations.

IEC 60947-2 Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear - Part 2: Circuit-breakers. Specifies breaking capacity ratings and selection criteria.

IEC 61363-1:1998 Short-circuit current calculation for three-phase a.c. systems - Part 1: Factors for the calculation of short-circuit currents.

ANSI/IEEE C37.010-2016 Application Guide for AC High-Voltage Circuit Breakers. Provides guidance for circuit breaker selection and application.

Supporting Standards & Guidelines

National Electrical Code (NEC) Article 110.9 Interrupting Rating - Requires equipment to have interrupting rating sufficient for available fault current.

IEC 60050 - International Electrotechnical Vocabulary International standards for electrical terminology and definitions.

NEMA Publications National Electrical Manufacturers Association standards for electrical equipment.

Further Reading

• Electrical Installation Guide - Schneider Electric - Comprehensive guide to electrical installation best practices

Note: Standards and codes are regularly updated. Always verify you're using the current adopted edition applicable to your project's location. Consult with local authorities having jurisdiction (AHJ) for specific requirements.

Disclaimer: This guide provides general technical information based on international electrical standards. Always verify calculations with applicable local electrical codes (NEC, IEC, BS 7671, etc.) and consult licensed electrical engineers or electricians for actual installations. Electrical work should only be performed by qualified professionals. Component ratings and specifications may vary by manufacturer.